Crime & Law Elections Foreign Affairs Policy Foreign Adversaries Border & Invasion Economy & Energy The Receipts

Texas Democrat's Law-and-Order Pitch Meets His Own Discipline File

Sophia Grant
Sophia Grant •

Johnny Garcia built his House campaign on nearly two decades in the Bexar County Sheriff's Office. Newly obtained records show two unpaid suspensions, including one after his service weapon was stolen from his car.

Texas Democrat's Law-and-Order Pitch Meets His Own Discipline File

A Democratic congressional candidate in Texas who has built his campaign around a career in law enforcement was suspended twice without pay as a Bexar County sheriff's deputy, including once after he left his service weapon in a vehicle where it was stolen.

Johnny Garcia, now running in Texas' newly redrawn 35th Congressional District, served a three-day suspension in 2009 and a five-day suspension in 2020, according to disciplinary records obtained through a public records request.

The file lands less than three weeks before Election Day and puts fresh scrutiny on the public safety message at the center of his bid against Republican Carlos De La Cruz, an Air Force veteran.

A Cell Phone in a Secure Jail, Then a Stolen Glock

The first case dates to 2009, when Garcia carried a personal cell phone into a secured area of the county jail. The suspension notice said he had been told repeatedly that bringing phones or electronic equipment into that area violated department policy.

"You have been instructed multiple times not to bring cellular phones or electronic equipment into the secured area," the notice read, citing insubordination and conduct that would seriously impair job effectiveness. He was suspended without pay for three days.

Eleven years later came the second case, and it was more serious. Garcia left his Glock pistol, four magazines and his badge in his car, contrary to department policy. The items were later stolen.

A disciplinary report said the equipment "was not properly secured and was kept temporarily in your vehicle against Bexar County Sheriff's policy," calling the conduct negligent and a clear violation of departmental procedures. Garcia received a five-day suspension without pay.

The firearm was recovered after Garcia reported it missing. No additional discipline followed either incident.

Sheriff's Office: Discipline Followed Civil Service Rules

The Bexar County Sheriff's Office said both cases were handled under county Civil Service Commission guidelines and that the punishments were final.

"Deputy Johnny Garcia served a 3-day unpaid suspension for bringing an electronic device into a secure facility, and a 5-day unpaid suspension for failing to properly secure county issued equipment," Deputy Noel Diaz said in a statement. "All deputies are required to maintain complete knowledge of the Civil Service Commission policies. Disciplinary actions are handled independently on single incidents."

The department declined to say how frequently suspensions of that kind are imposed or what other discipline it would weigh before suspending a deputy.

A Career at the Center of the Campaign

Garcia joined the sheriff's office at 21. He worked in the county jail and later served as a hostage negotiator, and he has not held elected office before.

He has made that record the core of his pitch, describing himself as "an old school Democrat" who believes "true public safety means more than tough talk." His platform lists border security as a top priority alongside affordability and protecting programs such as Social Security, and he has said he saw border weakness firsthand, arguing that President Biden failed the country at the southern line.

Confronted with the records, his campaign pointed back to his service. "As a sheriff's deputy, I've spent nearly two decades putting my own safety on the line to protect my community to keep violent criminals off our streets," Garcia said. "These politicized claims are Republicans' desperate attempts to distract from the fact that tariffs and his war in Iran have made everything more expensive for working families."

That answer cuts to the shape of the race. Garcia is not running as a national progressive. He is running as the cop on the ballot, and every Republican attack from here will be measured against that image.

Why the 35th District Matters

Garcia is competing for a seat left open by Rep. Greg Casar, the former Congressional Progressive Caucus chairman, who shifted to the neighboring 37th District after Texas Republicans redrew the map last year. Casar won the old district 67.4 percent to 32.6 percent in 2024, but the new lines pulled the seat into serious contention.

Casar attacked the map directly when he announced the move, saying the president and governor "rammed through maps designed to kick people like me out of office." The Texas remap is one front in the broader midterm redistricting wars that have reshuffled House battlegrounds from Missouri to the Rio Grande.

The district covers parts of Bexar County and the San Antonio area. Garcia cleared his primary in May and now heads into the Nov. 3 general election as one of the Democrats' tougher holds in a state where the party is already stretched thin.

What to Watch Before Nov. 3

Republicans will keep the disciplinary file in rotation through the closing weeks, framing it as a credibility problem for a candidate selling himself as the law-and-order Democrat. Garcia will answer with two decades on the job, the recovery of the weapon, and the argument that his opponents are changing the subject.

The deeper question is whether the Texas remap did what Republican mapmakers intended. If the 35th flips, it becomes a case study in how redrawn lines converted a safe Democratic seat into a genuine fight. If Garcia holds, Democrats get a rare proof point that their incumbents can survive the new geography.

Either way, the closing three weeks will test something simpler: whether a law enforcement resume still sells when the paperwork behind it is on the front page.