Crime & Law Elections Foreign Affairs Policy Foreign Adversaries Border & Invasion Economy & Energy The Receipts

Haley Stevens Crosses Party Lines to Endorse Mike Rogers in Michigan Senate Race

Nathan Kline
Nathan Kline •

Rep. Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers two days before Election Day, blowing up her party's closing message in the race that will help decide the Senate majority.

Haley Stevens Crosses Party Lines to Endorse Mike Rogers in Michigan Senate Race

Rep. Haley Stevens crossed party lines on Sunday and endorsed Republican Mike Rogers for the U.S. Senate, a defection two days before Election Day that tears open the Democratic coalition in the race that will help decide control of the chamber. Stevens made the announcement in a two-minute video after appearing beside Rogers at a Detroit church service, telling supporters she remains "a very proud Democrat" even as she abandoned her own party's nominee. The move lands as a direct blow to Abdul El-Sayed, the progressive who narrowly beat her in the August primary and has spent the fall trying to hold moderate, Black and Jewish Democrats together.

Her explanation was blunt. El-Sayed, she said, had told her she was no longer welcome in his campaign. "And he's right," Stevens said. "And that's why I am endorsing Mike Rogers for the United States Senate today."

A Church Service, a Split Screen, and a Party Unraveling

Stevens and her fiance, Jason Turkish, sat in the pews at Perfecting Church north of Detroit alongside Rogers and his wife, Kristi. Turkish had already said publicly last week that he would vote for Rogers, arguing the Democratic nominee had not done enough to answer the Jewish community's concerns. By Sunday morning the congresswoman had followed him.

A few miles away, El-Sayed was at a separate service trying to project unity, flanked by Rep. Debbie Dingell of Michigan, Rep. Jim Clyburn of South Carolina, Sen. Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland and state Sen. Mallory McMorrow, who dropped out of the Senate primary before voting began. The nominee spoke for about ten minutes and never mentioned the defection.

"It's in churches like this, in pews like the ones in which you sit, that the foundation of my life was built," El-Sayed told the congregation.

Dingell had spent the week arranging a joint appearance meant to showcase Democratic solidarity in the closing days. She scrapped it, she said, after the feud turned into a public spectacle, and she asked Stevens to stay away. "I'm the one who pulled it because it had become way too distracting," Dingell said. "The bishop was getting upset, because this is a real church service."

How a Primary Wound Reopened in the Final Week

Stevens won Wayne and Oakland counties in the August primary, carrying the Black and Jewish voters who anchor the Democratic base in metro Detroit, but El-Sayed edged her statewide. She promised afterward to help him however she could. The two have not appeared together since a unity breakfast two days after his win.

The primary itself was among the bitterest in the country this year. Each candidate accused the other of personal attacks, tens of millions in outside money poured into the race, and the American Israel Public Affairs Committee's affiliated super PAC backed Stevens. El-Sayed, a former Wayne County health director who also served as Michigan's public health chief, campaigns on Medicare for All and refuses corporate PAC money, a platform that energizes the party's left wing and unsettles the moderates who decide general elections in Michigan.

The rupture became public in stages. On Wednesday, Turkish told The Detroit News he would vote for Rogers. Hours later Stevens went on CNN, restated her support for El-Sayed, and urged his campaign to "shut out the hate and call it out." On Friday she demanded that he condemn an ad from an independent left-wing group that tied American support for Israel to high grocery prices.

"Abdul promises to get money out of politics," Stevens wrote. "He can begin by getting Israel out of his explanation for everything Michigan cannot afford."

El-Sayed answered that the ad was not his and that he disagreed with its contents. "So while Congresswoman Stevens seems intent on relitigating a primary that ended three months ago, let's all focus on the task at hand," he said. In her video, Stevens tied her decision to El-Sayed's association with streamer Hasan Piker and to what she described as a choice about education and who speaks for Michigan.

The defection is not the first crack in El-Sayed's coalition. More than 400 Jewish Democrats in Michigan, including donors and synagogue leaders who spent decades backing his party, had already broken with their nominee and endorsed Rogers.

Rogers' Opening in a Margin-of-Error Race

Rogers is a former congressman who represented Michigan for 15 years after a career as an FBI agent, and he lost the 2024 Senate race by fewer than 20,000 votes. He has run the general election almost entirely at disaffected Democrats, launching a Democrats for Mike Rogers coalition in Detroit and telling the crowd, "You have a home with us."

The polling explains the strategy. An AARP survey released Thursday put El-Sayed at 48 percent and Rogers at 47 percent among likely voters, inside the survey's 3.3-point margin of error. A Fox News poll earlier in the fall had Rogers ahead 51-47, powered by near-unanimous Republican support while El-Sayed's backing among non-socialist Democrats lagged at 69 percent. An average of recent surveys compiled by Decision Desk HQ showed El-Sayed narrowly ahead at 44-42.

Republicans need a net gain of a handful of seats to take the majority, and Michigan is one of their best pickups on the map. The seat is open because Democratic Sen. Gary Peters is retiring, and Democrats have treated holding it as a firewall for the final two years of Trump's second term.

What the Final 48 Hours Will Tell Us

El-Sayed's closing argument now has to compete with a story about his own party's most prominent primary rival campaigning for his opponent. Democrats insist the base is behind him, and early voting has been underway since Oct. 24, which means a large share of ballots are already locked in and immune to Sunday's news.

The damage will be measured where Stevens ran strongest. Wayne County, which includes Detroit, and neighboring Oakland County will decide the Senate race, and both depend on turnout from Black and Jewish voters who have now watched the nominee's coalition fracture in public. An endorsement does not transfer voters automatically, but it hands moderates who were already looking for permission to cross over a prominent Democrat to follow.

Rogers, meanwhile, gets the closing image every challenger wants: a sitting Democratic congresswoman standing with him in a house of worship, days before the vote, saying her own party's nominee pushed her out. Michigan settles the rest on Tuesday, and Washington will read the result as a verdict on how deep the Democratic fracture runs.