Crime & Law Elections Foreign Affairs Policy Foreign Adversaries Border & Invasion Economy & Energy The Receipts

Sherrill Orders New Jersey Lieutenant Governor to Resign After Ethics Report Finds Sexual Harassment

Alex Thompson
Alex Thompson •

New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill called on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell to resign Thursday after an independent investigation substantiated sexual harassment and repeated state ethics violations, giving him until Friday to step down.

Sherrill Orders New Jersey Lieutenant Governor to Resign After Ethics Report Finds Sexual Harassment

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill called on Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell to resign Thursday after an independent investigation substantiated a finding of sexual harassment and a documented pattern of state ethics violations. The governor announced the findings in a public statement and gave Caldwell until Friday to step down, saying his departure is necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents.

The report, released with redacted exhibits, was initiated by the state's Chief Ethics Officer and conducted by a respected former state Attorney General. It concluded that Caldwell engaged in serious and repeated violations of state policy and failed to uphold the responsibilities of his office. The findings land barely nine months into a term that began with Caldwell taking office alongside Sherrill in January.

What the Investigation Concluded

Investigators examined two questions: whether Caldwell violated the New Jersey State Policy Prohibiting Discrimination in the Workplace, and whether he violated the Code of Conduct for the Governor, adopted under Sherrill's Executive Order No. 3, along with the Uniform Ethics Code that applies to state officials. The answer to both was yes.

Sherrill said the most serious finding involved workplace harassment of a staff member. According to the investigative report, the conduct was not isolated but part of a pattern that continued despite multiple warnings and mandated trainings. In the governor's words, the substantiated finding of sexual harassment is extremely troubling, and the lapses reflected a pattern of behavior that does not meet the standards of her administration.

The report also found that Caldwell misused his position in ways that went beyond the harassment claim, including bringing uninvited guests into ticketed events on at least seven occasions.

Promotion Requests, Warnings and a Mid-Investigation Email

According to the report, Caldwell twice tried to secure a government promotion for a woman with whom he was romantically involved. He admitted to investigators that he did not disclose the personal nature of that relationship when he made the requests, leaving the officials he contacted unaware of the conflict they were being drawn into.

The timing is a central problem. On May 26, 2026, Caldwell used his state email account to recommend the promotion -- less than one month after he had been admonished and trained on workplace conduct and ethics matters, and only four days after the Chief Ethics Officer formally notified him that he was under investigation. Rather than pausing, he continued.

Separately, staffers told investigators that Caldwell was searching for what they described as a "first lady," and that he assigned one of his staffers to help find him a partner. That same staffer alleged he made sexually inappropriate comments to her, including a remark that she and a friend were ambitious and successful women who needed a man in a position to help them, followed by a crude reference to younger men.

Accountability Inside the Governor's Own Office

The case is unfolding as Capitol Hill continues untangling its own misconduct files. This week's report echoes the same standard that produced a bipartisan House censure of Rep. Chuck Edwards, a 413-2 vote that made clear that behavior once tolerated in official Washington now carries a price.

Sherrill leaned directly into that contrast. She said she holds everyone in her administration to the highest ethical standard, that leaders have an obligation to ensure everyone on an organization is bought in and able to succeed, and that she would not accept a culture that sweeps misconduct under the rug. As a former federal prosecutor, she said the investigation was thorough and impartial and that her administration would do what is right rather than what is politically expedient.

The political stakes are real. New Jersey governors run on a joint ticket with their lieutenant governor, so Sherrill cannot simply distance herself from the man she campaigned alongside. She has instead moved to define the story as accountability, drawing a deliberate line between her office and what she described as a culture of deference to powerful men.

What Happens Next

Caldwell has until Friday to resign. He has not yet said publicly whether he will. If he steps down, Sherrill would name a replacement under the state's succession rules, and the episode would end with a governor cleaning house inside her own administration.

If he refuses, the governor's office has not laid out its next move, and the pressure campaign shifts to the Legislature. New Jersey voters, who handed Sherrill and Caldwell the executive branch less than a year ago, will be watching how quickly the state resolves a standoff that has already put a national spotlight on Trenton.

For now, the clock is the story. A written deadline gives the lieutenant governor one night to decide whether to leave on his own terms or force a fight he is unlikely to win.