Crime & Law Elections Foreign Affairs Policy Foreign Adversaries Border & Invasion Economy & Energy The Receipts

New York Governor's Pardon Kills Supreme Court Immigration Showdown

Isabella Cruz
Isabella Cruz •

The Supreme Court dismissed a major immigration detention case a month before argument after New York Gov. Kathy Hochul pardoned the convicted felon at the center of the fight.

New York Governor's Pardon Kills Supreme Court Immigration Showdown

The Supreme Court on Sept. 11 dismissed a closely watched immigration case that had been set for oral argument next month, after New York's Democratic governor erased the criminal conviction at the center of the dispute with a last-minute pardon.

The case, Genalo v. Black, asked whether the federal government can hold immigrants convicted of serious crimes for months, or even years, without ever giving them a bond hearing. Argument had been scheduled for Oct. 13. It will not happen.

The dismissal is a real setback for the Trump administration's immigration enforcement agenda -- and an unusually direct example of a state clemency power being used to shut down a federal case before the justices could decide it.

A Pardon That Made the Case Disappear

Gov. Kathy Hochul granted clemency to Keisy Guerrero Mariano on Aug. 28, part of a group of six pardons announced by her office. Mariano, identified in court papers as Keisy G.M., is a Dominican national and a lawful permanent resident of the United States since 2011.

He pleaded guilty in 2015 to second-degree assault in a New York state court and was sentenced to two years in prison, though he was released after 19 months for good behavior. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers arrested him at his Bronx home in October 2020, determining that the conviction made him deportable and subject to mandatory detention under Section 1226(c) of the Immigration and Nationality Act.

Mariano argued he would face torture if returned to his homeland. Immigration judges rejected that claim and ordered him removed. He then spent roughly 21 months in immigration detention without a bond hearing, and was released in July 2022 under a nationwide injunction that freed detainees deemed at high risk from COVID-19.

Hochul's pardon wiped out the aggravated felony conviction that made Mariano deportable, so he was no longer subject to mandatory detention. The live controversy the administration wanted the justices to resolve disappeared with it.

How the Fight Reached the High Court

A federal district judge denied Mariano's request for release in November 2021, concluding the government had not unreasonably delayed his case. That changed in May 2024, when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled that once mandatory detention becomes unreasonably prolonged, due process requires a bond hearing.

Under that ruling, the government must prove by clear and convincing evidence that a detainee is a flight risk or a danger to the public before continuing to hold him. The Trump administration appealed in January, and the Supreme Court agreed in June to hear the case, putting a major test of detention authority on the calendar.

The dispute had already narrowed once. A second plaintiff, Carol Williams Black, dropped out after leaving the United States and filing a declaration that he would not return. Black was convicted in New York in 2000 of sexually abusing a minor under the age of 11, which the government cited as grounds for removal.

With Mariano pardoned and Black gone, Solicitor General D. John Sauer and the respondent's counsel, Cecillia Wang of the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, filed a joint stipulation to dismiss. The court granted it within hours, formally ending the case a month before argument.

An Enforcement Fight That Is Not Finished

Sauer said in a separate filing that the questions raised by the case remain very much alive, and that the administration will seek new cases that still allow the court to resolve the issues during its 2026-27 term. That pledge signals the Justice Department has no intention of letting the Second Circuit's rule stand as the final word on how long criminal aliens can be held.

The administration has argued that mandatory detention is a critical tool for removing dangerous offenders and that allowing endless bond litigation would bog down removal proceedings. Officials have pointed to the case's own facts, including the assault conviction that triggered Mariano's detention, as evidence that these hearings are being used to slow, not speed, removals.

The Second Circuit's 2024 precedent stays in force across New York, Connecticut and Vermont, where the Department of Homeland Security must now provide bond hearings to detainees held for prolonged periods under Section 1226(c). Legal observers were quick to fault the pardon. Iowa Solicitor General Eric Wessan said it was "pretty wild to fully pardon an aggravated felon" both to block deportation and to stop the Supreme Court from ruling on the issue at all.

What to Watch Next

The administration is expected to move quickly to find another pending case raising the same due process question, possibly from a different circuit, so the Supreme Court can settle it during the upcoming term. Until then, federal detention practice in the three states covered by the Second Circuit will be governed by the 2024 decision.

The pardon also hands Republicans a fresh argument as midterm voting gets under way: that Democratic governors are willing to use clemency powers to shield criminal aliens from federal immigration enforcement. Watch for the administration's next filing, the search for a replacement case, and whether more governors face pressure over similar pardons.