A Mombasa court convicted Paul Nthenge Mackenzie and 28 co-defendants of murdering 190 children and one adult in a starvation cult, closing the first phase of a case that exposed years of official inaction.
A Kenyan court convicted a self-proclaimed pastor and 28 co-defendants on Monday of murdering 191 people, all but one of them children, in a starvation cult that turned an 800-acre farm into a mass grave. The ruling in Mombasa closes the first phase of a case that has hung over the country since police began pulling bodies out of the Shakahola Forest in 2023.
Paul Nthenge Mackenzie, who built a following through the Good News International Church, was accused of instructing his adherents to starve themselves and their children to death so they could "meet Jesus." He and the other accused pleaded not guilty in 2024 to 191 counts of murder.
"I am satisfied that the prosecution has proved the case against all the 29 accused persons for the murder of 190 children and one adult," the presiding judge said as the verdict was read.
The cult's base sat inland from the coastal resort town of Malindi, in a stretch of scrubland that became known as the Shakahola Forest. What began in April 2023 as a rescue operation for a handful of emaciated followers turned into a months-long exhumation.
Hundreds of shallow graves were opened. The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights put the death toll at 429 in 2024, and the count of recovered bodies has continued to climb past 400 as investigators work through sites tied to the same network. Some victims remain unidentified.
The scale overwhelmed local services. Excavations were paused at points because morgues along the coast ran out of space for the dead. Families traveled from rural villages to Mombasa for Monday's ruling, some of them carrying the names of eight or nine relatives who never came home.
Courts elsewhere have delivered similar reckonings this year, including the Sri Lanka High Court's conviction of 14 men over the 2019 Easter Sunday bombings. In Kenya, the reckoning arrived with a far larger body count and a far simpler question: how did this happen in the open for years?
Prosecutors described a doctrine engineered for maximum control. Mackenzie, they alleged, initiated and directed extreme fasting on the ranch and built what the state called a "structured hierarchy of death" -- children were to die first, followed by teenagers, then women, then men.
Followers were reportedly split into smaller groups assigned biblical names. Investigators believe those groups died together and were buried together, which is why the graves were found in clusters rather than scattered across the property.
State pathologists concluded that most of the children died of starvation. Others showed signs of asphyxia, neck compression and traumatic head injury, findings that undercut any claim that this was a passive religious exercise in which people simply chose to stop eating.
Defense lawyers argued the case rested largely on circumstantial evidence, hearsay accounts and inconclusive forensic findings. The court rejected that framing for all 29 defendants.
The most damning part of the record is not what Mackenzie preached. It is how long the state knew and did nothing.
He founded the Good News International Church in 2003 and built branches in Nairobi and along the coast that drew thousands of devotees. He claimed the church closed in 2019, yet his influence continued to spread online, pulling followers from across the country to a remote ranch with no oversight.
Mackenzie was arrested in 2017 on radicalization charges and was acquitted. He was arrested again in 2019 in connection with two child deaths at Shakahola and was released on bail. Only after a rights group tipped off authorities in April 2023, and some followers were rescued, did the full operation begin.
In January, he was charged over another 52 bodies found at a nearby village. The pattern is a case study in what happens when early warnings are logged, filed and forgotten -- and when bail, bureaucratic hesitation and a reluctance to confront a self-styled man of God are allowed to outrank the safety of children.
"We are expecting a ruling that will be a lesson to the whole public, so that such kinds of things will not happen again," said Francis Wanje, 62, who lost eight family members in Shakahola, including his daughter and two grandchildren. He has spoken bluntly about the government's initial failure to act.
The murder conviction does not end Mackenzie's legal exposure. He still faces separate manslaughter and terrorism charges, and the additional counts tied to the 52 bodies found at the neighboring site remain in the pipeline. Sentencing in the murder case now moves forward, with the possibility of the harshest penalties available under Kenyan law.
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions called the verdict momentous. "Getting a conviction of such counts is not something that comes that easily," Director Renson Ingonga told reporters outside the courthouse.
Kenyan lawmakers and rights groups are now pressing for tougher regulation of religious organizations, arguing that the country's registration and oversight rules are too loose to catch a preacher who converts a congregation into a closed compound. That debate will test whether Kenya can draw a workable line between protecting worship and policing fraud, coercion and abuse.
For American readers, the case carries a warning that does not depend on geography. Religious liberty is a bedrock principle, and it protects the right to worship freely, to raise children in a faith and to preach unpopular things. It does not protect a man who starves children to death and calls it salvation. The first duty of any government is the protection of the innocent, and the Shakahola dead are the price of a state that waited too long to enforce it.