A Wall Street Journal report reveals Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman skipped the funeral of three detectives slain in a York County ambush because it was too long -- and details a broader pattern of dodged meetings and skipped duties now fueling talk of a 2028 primary challenge.
A sweeping Wall Street Journal report on Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman shows a first-term Democrat who routinely ducks the work of his office -- and who declined to attend the funeral of three detectives slain in a York County ambush because the service was, in his words, too long. The report, built on text messages and internal communications from Fetterman's own staff, has ignited a firestorm among Pennsylvania Democrats, several of whom are now openly talking about challenging him in the 2028 primary.
The funeral Fetterman skipped honored Detective Sergeant Cody Becker, Detective Mark Baker, and Detective Isaiah Emenheiser of the Northern York County Regional Police Department. The three were shot and killed on September 17, 2025, while serving an arrest warrant at a home in North Codorus Township.
The officers Fetterman declined to honor gave their lives doing the most dangerous job in law enforcement. The three detectives were part of a team attempting to serve an arrest warrant in the 1800 block of Haar Road when a 24-year-old gunman opened fire in what investigators described as a calculated ambush. A fourth Northern York County Regional detective and a York County Sheriff's deputy were wounded in the attack before the suspect was killed in an exchange of gunfire.
Becker, Baker, and Emenheiser were remembered at a public funeral at Living Word Community Church in Red Lion on September 25, 2025, with fellow officers, families, and community members paying tribute to their service. Their sacrifice was honored again at the national level in May, when Vice President JD Vance recognized the three detectives during the Peace Officers Memorial Service in Washington -- the kind of gesture their home-state senator declined to make.
The messages and communications obtained from Fetterman's staff lay out the senator's reasoning in blunt terms: the ceremony was too long. The excuse landed especially hard in a state where fallen officers are traditionally honored with full department and elected-official participation.
The funeral was not the only duty Fetterman dodged. The report details how he claimed a stomach bug to get out of a meeting with three paralyzed veterans, only to appear on Fox News later the same day to discuss Israel with no visible signs of illness. It also shows him skipping a scheduled sit-down with a state lawmaker so he could meet instead with former college basketball coach Bruce Pearl, and dismissively suggesting that children's hospital representatives concerned about vaccines simply wanted free trips to Washington.
The portrait extends to the Senate itself. Colleagues and staff describe a senator who churns through staff, skips hearings, and blows off constituents -- even those with meetings on the calendar. Fetterman, 57, did not comment for the report.
Fetterman long ago alienated much of his party's base by visiting President Donald Trump at Mar-a-Lago after the 2024 election, backing several of Trump's cabinet nominees, and breaking with Democrats over Israel. What makes this moment different is that the criticism is no longer about his politics. It is about whether he is doing the job at all.
Representative Brendan Boyle of Philadelphia did not hold back, calling Fetterman a disgrace and saying Pennsylvania deserves better than a lazy trust fund baby who is too lazy to do the job. Representative Chris Deluzio of Allegheny County said the report shows a man with no sense of duty who is not up for the high office he was elected to, adding that Pennsylvania Democrats will do something about it in 2028. Former Representative Conor Lamb, who has also been mentioned as a possible primary rival, said the report confirms Fetterman simply needs to quit.
Fetterman's collapse in Democratic standing did not happen overnight. He suffered a stroke in May 2022 and went on to defeat Republican Mehmet Oz that November, becoming one of the party's most recognizable new senators. In the years since, he has visited President Trump at Mar-a-Lago, backed several of Trump's cabinet picks, and become one of Israel's strongest defenders in the Senate -- breaks with his party that fueled a historic slide in his support among Pennsylvania Democrats.
The Journal's reporting strikes at something different than political apostasy. Skipping the funeral of murdered detectives, dodging paralyzed veterans, and brushing off constituents are not ideological choices. They are the fundamentals of showing up, and the messages from his own staff suggest he simply does not want to.
Boyle, Deluzio, and Lamb are all rumored to be weighing bids for Fetterman's seat, which is up in 2028. Recent polling in Pennsylvania has been brutal for the incumbent: statewide surveys found roughly 75 percent of Democratic voters would prefer someone else in the seat.
Fetterman has not responded publicly to the report, and his office offered no comment when the Journal reached out. The silence may not last. With a 2028 primary threat forming inside his own party and a national spotlight suddenly on his attendance record, the senator faces a simple choice: answer the criticism with action, or let the record speak for itself.
For Pennsylvanians, the stakes go beyond one man's work habits. The detectives Fetterman skipped were serving a warrant in the line of duty when they were murdered -- the exact kind of sacrifice elected officials are expected to honor without hesitation. Vice President Vance and national leaders found time to recognize them. Their own senator could not.
The report also raises questions about Fetterman's reliability as a possible swing vote in a Senate where every seat matters. If his staff cannot keep him in hearings and constituents cannot get meetings, allies and adversaries alike are left guessing which version of the senator will show up when a decisive vote lands.
Whether Fetterman can rebuild trust with the voters who sent him to Washington remains an open question. What the Journal's reporting makes clear is that in Pennsylvania, the conversation about his future has already begun -- and it is no longer just Republicans asking whether he deserves another term.